The Silent Killer of Teams: Lack of Trust

Jessica Leonard • August 7, 2025

You walk into the room and suddenly… the chatter stops.
Morale dips. Gossip spreads. Productivity tanks.


Trust isn’t just “nice to have.” It’s the foundation of every winning team, and when it cracks, everything else falls apart.


Learn how emotional intelligence and self-accountability can rebuild trust and save your culture before it’s too late.


You turn the corner in your office and feel your stomach drop. The once-lively chatter fades as you appear. A trusted employee has lied to you, and whispers of gossip begin to rise. Complaints pile up, morale feels shaky, and you can’t quite put your finger on what’s wrong, but something definitely is.


More often than not, the root issue is trust.


When trust begins to erode in a team or organization, the symptoms are subtle at first but quickly compound. Employees stop communicating openly. High performers start to question their leaders. Mediocre performers disengage further. Productivity declines, and metrics begin to suffer. At this point, the damage can feel irreparable.


Trust is the foundation of every successful business and high-performing team. When it’s strong, people thrive. When it weakens, everything suffers.


As a leader, one of your most critical responsibilities is to monitor the health of trust within your team, and act decisively at the first sign of trouble. It’s not just an HR issue or a “soft skill.” It’s a core business imperative. Teams that trust each other and their leaders perform better, innovate more, and weather challenges with greater resilience.


So, how can leaders and organizations regain lost trust?


It starts with emotional intelligence.


According to a Harvard Business Review study, the two most commonly underdeveloped leadership traits are emotional self-awareness and empathy, both of which are essential for building and restoring trust (Goleman, Boyatzis, & McKee, 2013). When leaders understand their own emotional impact and genuinely empathize with their teams, trust naturally follows and self accountability improves.


Further research backs this up. A meta-analysis published in the Leadership & Organization Development Journal found that emotionally intelligent leaders foster stronger, more resilient teams (Harms & Credé, 2010). These leaders are better at navigating conflict, supporting their people, and creating a culture of psychological safety by utilizing their people’s skills and building an environment of shared purpose.


At the heart of regaining trust is consistent, authentic behavior, a.k.a self accountability: saying what you mean, following through on commitments, listening more than you speak, and creating communication platforms for candid conversations. It’s also about recognizing when things are off and having the personal courage to address it.


This is a core focus of the work we do with our clients. We help leaders uncover the invisible trust gaps holding their teams back and guide them in developing the emotional intelligence and strategies to rebuild those bridges.

Worried you might have a trust issue? Don’t ignore the signs. Trust is hard to earn and easy to lose, but with the right approach, it can be rebuilt.


Let us help you strengthen the foundation your team truly needs to thrive.

Arrowhead Leadership Blog

By Brittany Simmons August 25, 2025
In today's dynamic work environment, organizations are constantly seeking an edge, a way to attract top talent, foster high performance, and, crucially, retain their most valuable asset: their people. While many factors contribute to employee satisfaction and longevity, one often underestimated yet profoundly impactful element is accountability . Far from being a buzzword, true accountability, when cultivated effectively, acts as a powerful catalyst, directly influencing employee engagement, productivity, organizational culture, and ultimately, retention.  At Arrowhead Leadership Consulting, we consistently observe that a strong culture of accountability doesn't just improve performance; it builds a foundation of trust and respect that makes employees want to stay. When individuals and teams are genuinely accountable, they feel a sense of ownership, purpose, and value, all of which are critical for long-term commitment.
By Seth Allen August 25, 2025
What’s Causing the Silent Drain? Your culture’s crumbling. Your best people are quitting. Projects are missing the mark. But the issue isn’t always obvious, it’s often hidden in plain sight.  This silent drain is costing companies millions... and it all comes down to one thing: Leadership gaps.
Title card:
By Scott Morris August 7, 2025
From Turnover to Team Loyalty: Discover how great leaders transform turnover into loyalty by developing people, building strong cultures, and creating teams that thrive.
By Sarah Carter August 7, 2025
Think Gen Z is “leadership-averse”? Think again. They’re not missing motivation, they’re missing direction . Open-door policies won’t cut it anymore. You need intentional leadership: coaching, mentoring, and meaningful conversations that connect daily work to the bigger mission.  Want to build loyalty and purpose in your team? This blog shows you how.
Title card:
By Eric Lopez August 7, 2025
Conflict isn’t caused by difficult personalities—it’s fueled by weak accountability. Learn how Structured Empowerment™ stops project derailments for good.
By Cory Brown August 7, 2025
Weak leadership drains high-pressure industries through turnover, safety risks, lost productivity, and stalled growth. Learn the 5 hidden costs—and how to stop them.
A black and white photo of two people shaking hands in front of blinds.
November 20, 2024
Alleviate Unmet Expectations
A person is holding a baseball in a baseball glove.
March 11, 2024
A concerning trend is emerging in the business world, illustrated through a baseball analogy. Picture a fly ball soaring between center field and right field…which one will catch it? The right fielder assumes the center fielder will make the catch, while the center fielder believes it's the right fielder's responsibility—resulting in the ball dropping between them. This scenario mirrors the current state of leader development in many businesses. In this analogy, Operations represents the centerfielder, HR takes on the role of the right fielder, and the ball symbolizes leader development. Unfortunately, businesses are fumbling the ball. We regularly hear Operations Managers claim, "I am too busy running the company to focus on developing leaders. Leader development falls under the 'people' function, so it's HR's responsibility." Conversely, HR Managers assert, "I am solely accountable for hiring and payroll. Leader development is Operations' duty." Consequently, few companies take deliberate action to develop their leaders. The outcome is frustration among Operations Managers due to the insufficient proficiency and efficiency of junior leaders. HR Managers grapple with a surge in employee issues, and employees express frustration at the lack of personal development. The solution lies in fostering communication between the outfielders (Operations and HR) and building a purposeful leader development program for the company. Here are steps to initiate a leader development program: Begin by defining the values/traits desired in leaders in your company. HR can then incorporate these values into recruitment, hiring, and onboarding processes. Operations and HR collaborate to establish a training program that instills these values in employees and junior leaders. Operations managers can reinforce these traits during daily interactions on the job site. By following these three straightforward steps, companies can make substantial progress in developing their leaders and successfully catching the metaphorical ball. If your company requires assistance in this process, Arrowhead Leadership is here to help build your values and establish a sustainable leader development plan.
A baseball player is wearing a dodgers uniform and holding a glove.
January 15, 2024
The new year often brings new resolutions, or goals. Today, I want to help you break away from the majority of people who give up on their goals before January is even over. To illustrate the power of effective goal-setting, let's take a moment to explore Shohei Ohtani's goal-setting chart, a remarkable example of how clarity and structure can propel one towards unprecedented success. Shohei Ohtani, the multi-talented baseball phenomenon, has captivated the world not just with his athletic prowess but also with his meticulous approach to goal-setting. Ohtani's goal-setting chart is a visual representation of his primary goal, intermediate goals, and the subsequent daily, monthly, or weekly goals that lead him towards his ultimate objective. It serves as a testament to the impact a well-defined roadmap can have on achieving extraordinary feats. Now, let's unravel the secret sauce behind successful goal-setting. Whether you're an athlete, a business professional, or an aspiring entrepreneur, the key lies in crafting a comprehensive goal-setting blueprint. Here's how you can be successful in setting and keeping goals: